First Choice Florida manages a curated portfolio of vacation homes, condos, and beach houses across St. Augustine. We don’t aggregate every listing on the coast – we represent properties we know personally, work with owners directly, and keep our standards high.
Find your stay
Narrow by area, size, and the kind of trip you're planning - then browse our featured homes and full collection below.
No properties match these filters.
Try widening your search — clear a filter or two — or call us at 904-429-7373 and we’ll help find a fit.
Featured Vacation Rentals
Vacation homes & beach houses
Standalone homes with private space, multiple bedrooms, and (often) a yard or pool. Good for families, multi-generation groups, and longer stays.
Vacation Homes & Beach Houses
View all houses →
Vacation condos
Lower-maintenance stays in oceanfront and near-beach buildings. Most include shared pools and easy beach access. Best for couples and small families.
Vacation Condos
View all condos →
Pet-friendly rentals
Bringing your dog? These properties welcome pets (some with fees). Most are on quieter residential streets within a short walk of the beach.
Pet-Friendly Rentals
View all pet-friendly →
Looking for something specific?
Use the filter bar above to narrow by area, bedrooms, sleeps, pet-friendly, or pool. Still not finding it? Call 904-429-7373 and we’ll match you to the right property.