St. Augustine Vacation Rentals

A complete St. Augustine-based team that’s worked together for decades. First Choice Florida manages a wide range of vacation rentals across the area – beach houses, oceanfront condos, pet-friendly homes, and properties with pools. Book directly with us: no booking fees, no third-party markup, and real 24-hour support from the local team.

St. Augustine is the nation’s oldest continuously occupied city – founded in 1565 on the shore where Pedro Menéndez de Avilés believed he’d found the Fountain of Youth. The historic district preserves five centuries of layered architecture: the coquina-walled Castillo de San Marcos, the St. Augustine Lighthouse, Flagler’s gilded-age hotels.

Browse things to do, the best ghost tours, where to eat, or browse all our vacation rentals to find your stay.

Browse by Style

Just Added

More Properties to Explore

Island Retreat – Unit B

Island Retreat – Unit B

St. Augustine Beach
Studio 1 BA Sleeps 2

Beautiful remodeled studio in St. Augustine Beach with a king-sized bed, complete bath, and fully outfitted kitchen, steps from the beach! Located…

from $100/night
Casita 1860

Casita 1860

St. Augustine Historic District
1 BR 1 BA Sleeps 2

As you enter through the front door, the pride of ownership is evident at every turn. The living room features an antique…

from $125/night
Villas of Ocean Gate #341

Villas of Ocean Gate #341

St. Augustine Beach
4 BR 3 BA Sleeps 10

Spend your vacation in the largest townhouse condo in the area! Saint Augustine’s Villas of Ocean Gate offers 4 bedrooms and 3…

from $185/night
Anastasia Condos #214

Anastasia Condos #214

St. Augustine Beach
2 BR 2 BA Sleeps 6

Anastasia Condos is the tallest oceanfront condominium complex on St. Augustine Beach (7 floors), with 3 elevators to quickly get to the…

from $120/night
Spanish Trace #241

Spanish Trace #241

Crescent Beach
2 BR 2 BA Sleeps 4

Wake up to the Atlantic from a comfortable second-floor condo where the ocean and the pool are both in view before you…

from $135/night
Captains Quarters 112

Captains Quarters 112

St. Augustine Beach
3 BR 2 BA Sleeps 8

Amenities include a swimming pool, a community grilling area, a garage, guest parking, an in-unit washer and dryer, and free wireless internet.…

from $235/night
Atlantic Bliss

Atlantic Bliss

Butler Beach
5 BR 3.5 BA Sleeps 16

**Atlantic Bliss** is an extraordinary and luxurious home that promises an unforgettable vacation experience. This stunning retreat is ideal for large families…

from $350/night
Among the Oaks

Among the Oaks

St. Augustine
2 BR 2 BA Sleeps 4

Among the Oaks is a beautifully maintained, custom-built modular home set on over an acre of land, offering privacy, space, and a…

from $100/night
Seaside at Anastasia G306

Seaside at Anastasia G306

St. Augustine Beach
3 BR 2 BA Sleeps 8

Located at Seaside at Anastasia, this stunning 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom penthouse offers fantastic ocean views and is undoubtedly the best condo in the…

from $135/night
Serenity by the Sea

Serenity by the Sea

St. Augustine Beach
2 BR 2.5 BA Sleeps 8

Tucked into a quiet beach neighborhood that backs right up to Anastasia State Park, Serenity by the Sea is a roomy island…

from $225/night
Sea Winds #75

Sea Winds #75

St. Augustine Beach
2 BR 2 BA Sleeps 6

Wake up on the quiet side of the island at this remodeled flat on St. Augustine Beach, where the sand is a…

from $115/night
Colony Reef 3101

Colony Reef 3101

Crescent Beach
3 BR 2 BA Sleeps 6

Colony Reef 3101 is a spacious 3-bedroom, 2-bath oceanfront condo located in the desirable Crescent Beach area of St. Augustine. Designed for…

from $135/night

Find Your Perfect St. Augustine Vacation Rental

Beach houses, condos, pet-friendly homes, and properties with pools - all managed by First Choice Florida since 1998.

Browse All 70+ Properties →