A complete St. Augustine-based team that’s worked together for decades. First Choice Florida manages a wide range of vacation rentals across the area – beach houses, oceanfront condos, pet-friendly homes, and properties with pools. Book directly with us: no booking fees, no third-party markup, and real 24-hour support from the local team.
St. Augustine is the nation’s oldest continuously occupied city – founded in 1565 on the shore where Pedro Menéndez de Avilés believed he’d found the Fountain of Youth. The historic district preserves five centuries of layered architecture: the coquina-walled Castillo de San Marcos, the St. Augustine Lighthouse, Flagler’s gilded-age hotels.
Browse things to do, the best ghost tours, where to eat, or browse all our vacation rentals to find your stay.

Beach homes for any size family - from compact retreats to multi-bedroom escapes.
Browse Houses →
Oceanfront and oceanview condos with the views you came to St. Augustine for.
Find a Condo →
Bring the whole family. Verified pet-friendly homes and condos across the area.
Bring the Pets →
Fanta Sea is located on Anastasia Island, just 10 minutes south of downtown Saint Augustine. Situated in a tranquil area, this beautiful…

Three bedrooms, two and a half bathrooms, and 1,623 square feet give this Quail Hollow townhome real room for a group of…

Hibiscus Resort Unit I-201 is a Remodeled 2nd floor condo which features a large living area, dining room and fully equipped kitchen…

Take in the spectacular views of Crescent Beach from your balcony. This up-to-date one bedroom one bath condo is on the second…

As you enter through the front door, the pride of ownership is evident at every turn. The living room features an antique…

Tucked into a quiet beach neighborhood that backs right up to Anastasia State Park, Serenity by the Sea is a roomy island…

Beautiful 2-bedroom, 1-bath ground floor unit with a covered patio. This completely remodeled space features granite counters and top-of-the-line appliances. It is…

**Beachside Bungalow** is located in Vilano Beach on Veterans Island. No matter where you are, it's just seconds away from the beach.…

A full wall of glass in the primary bedroom frames the Atlantic, and from the fourth floor of this gated oceanfront building…

Welcome to Coastal Village Retreat, where the Florida lifestyle awaits you. Nestled amidst stunning coastal oak trees in a serene residential neighborhood,…

The location is ideal! Coastal Cottage unit B provides everything you need to take advantage of this great location. Located on Saint…

Amenities include a swimming pool, a community grilling area, a garage, guest parking, an in-unit washer and dryer, and free wireless internet.…
Beach houses, condos, pet-friendly homes, and properties with pools - all managed by First Choice Florida since 1998.
Browse All 70+ Properties →