1017 A1A Beach Blvd, St. Augustine, FL, 32080 info@firstchoiceflorida.com
YouTube 904-429-7373 Facebook
First Choice Florida Vacation Rentals
BOOK DIRECT · NO FEES · LOCAL SINCE 1998
904-429-7373
Browse Rentals
  • House Rentals
  • Condo Rentals
  • Pet Friendly Rentals
  • Swimming Pools
  • Contact ▾
    • About First Choice
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Property Management
    • Local Resources
First Choice Florida
  • House Rentals
  • Condo Rentals
  • Pet Friendly Rentals
  • Swimming Pools
  • Contact ▾
    • About First Choice
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Property Management
    • Local Resources
904-429-7373
1017 A1A Beach Blvd, St. Augustine, FL, 32080
Skip to content
1017 A1A Beach Blvd, St. Augustine, FL, 32080904-429-7373info@firstchoiceflorida.com
First Choice Florida
St. Augustine Rentals
First Choice Florida
  • Rentals
    • Home Rentals
    • Condo Rentals
    • Pet Friendly Rentals
    • Homes with Pools
  • Property Management
Search:
  • House Rentals
  • Condo Rentals
  • Pet Friendly Rentals
  • Swimming Pools
  • Contact
    • About First Choice
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Property Management
    • Local Resources
close
  • 404 Page
  • About First Choice
    • Contact
    • Copyright Information
    • Disclaimer
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Privacy Policy
  • Google
  • Guest Info
    • Arrival
    • Coffee Makers in our Rentals
    • Departure — Condos
    • Departure — Vacation Homes
    • During Your Stay
    • Local Resources
    • Parking for Casita
    • Rules & Policies
    • Television Information
    • Tenant Terms & Conditions
    • Vacation Essentials
  • Hub: Buildings
  • Hub: Location — Butler Beach
  • Hub: Location — Crescent Beach
  • Hub: Location — St. Augustine
  • Hub: Location — St. Augustine Beach
  • Hub: Location — St. Augustine Historic District
  • Hub: Location — Summer Haven
  • Hub: Location — Vilano Beach
  • Hub: Neighborhoods
  • Hub: Tag — Condos
  • Hub: Tag — Homes
  • Hub: Tag — Oceanfront
  • Hub: Tag — Pet-Friendly
  • Hub: Tag — Pool
  • Hub: Vacation Rentals
  • Property Management
  • Sea Winds vs. Colony Reef
  • Send a Correction
  • St. Augustine Vacation Rentals | Houses, Condos & Beach Homes

Hub: Location — Butler Beach

First Choice Florida Vacation Rentals
A complete St. Augustine-based team that's worked together for decades.
1017 A1A Beach Blvd
St. Augustine, FL 32080
904-429-7373
info@firstchoiceflorida.com
Office hours: Mon-Fri 9-5
24-hour phone support available
Follow on Facebook

Are You a Property Owner?

Let First Choice Florida manage your vacation rental. Local expertise since 1998. Maximize bookings, minimize hassle.

Learn About Property Management →
Or call 904-429-7373 for a free property evaluation
  • About First Choice
  • Contact
  • Copyright Information
  • Disclaimer
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Local Resources
  • Privacy Policy
  • Property Management

We Serve

  • St. Augustine Beach
  • Vilano Beach
  • Crescent Beach
  • Butler Beach
  • Summer Haven
  • Historic District
St. Augustine Tourism Guide

Things to Do

  • Weekend Itinerary
  • Best Beaches
  • Best Ghost Tours
  • Best Restaurants
  • Things to Do with Kids
  • Pet-Friendly Guide
  • Historic Attractions

Visit SATG →

Sea Place #14245

Sea Place #14245

Butler Beach
from $125/night
Anastasia Condos #214

Anastasia Condos #214

St. Augustine Beach
from $125/night
Beach Therapy

Beach Therapy

Butler Beach
from $135/night
Spot something off on this page? Send a quick correction →

This site contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

© 2026 First Choice Florida Vacation Rentals, LLC. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy · Terms & Conditions
Go to Top