Margaritaville

Margaritaville is a multi-story Butler Beach pool home with ocean views and room for 12, built for easy, beach-focused St. Augustine getaways. This four bedroom, three bathroom house gives larger families or mixed-age groups 2,343 square feet across several levels, close to the sand. With a private pool, a fenced yard, and decks on nearly every floor, it is the kind of place where the beach, pool, and family time all matter.

The House

The home is laid out across multiple stories, with decks, porches, and a balcony that give guests several places to sit outside and take in the views. Inside, it has a casual coastal feel with plenty of natural light, tile floors, and ceiling fans. The living area is comfortable and practical, with couches, a television, cable or satellite service, DVD, and a stereo for movie nights after a long day outside.

The kitchen is a strong feature for a group stay. It is a full kitchen with cookware, dishes, utensils, refrigerator, stove, oven, microwave, dishwasher, toaster, and coffee maker. The kitchen island and dining spaces make it easy to handle breakfast before the beach, simple lunches between swims, or a family dinner without needing to go out every night.

The sleeping layout spreads across the levels. The four bedrooms hold a queen bed, a king bed, one room with two twin beds, and one room with a single bed, and the living room adds more single beds plus a sofa bed. That setup is useful for larger families, kids, grandparents, cousins, or friends traveling together. With three full bathrooms, guests are not all waiting on one bathroom to shower and get ready after beach or pool time. The home also includes a washing machine, clothes dryer, linens, towels, air conditioning, central heat, iron and board, and free Wi-Fi with 250+ Mbps speed.

Outside, the private pool is one of the big reasons to book. After a morning at the beach, guests can come back to the fenced pool area, cool off, and keep the day easy. The fenced yard adds practical outdoor space, and the multiple elevated decks look out across the neighborhood and toward the beach. Margaritaville is also pet-friendly, so travelers who do not want to leave the dog behind can bring it along for an additional pet fee.

Highlights

• 4 bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms
• Sleeps up to 12 guests
• 2,343 square feet across multiple levels
• Private pool with a fenced pool area and a fenced yard
• Multiple decks, porches, and a balcony with ocean, beach, and water views
• Full kitchen with island, washer and dryer, and free Wi-Fi (250+ Mbps)
• Pet-friendly

St. Augustine

Butler Beach is a quieter, more residential stretch of the St. Augustine coast. It sits south of the busier St. Augustine Beach pier area and north of Crescent Beach, giving visitors a relaxed beach setting without feeling cut off from restaurants, attractions, and historic downtown. Guests can spend most of the day close to the ocean, then drive north for dinner, shopping, or a night in the Historic District.

Historic St. Augustine is one of the best parts of staying here. You can start the day by the Atlantic, spend the afternoon in the private pool, and still head into town for the Castillo de San Marcos, St. George Street, the bayfront, museums, ghost tours, galleries, and dinner. Margaritaville works because it gives you the beach house first while keeping the rest of St. Augustine close enough to enjoy.

The Area

Butler Beach is where Margaritaville earns its keep. The neighborhood is laid-back and residential, with quiet streets where kids can ride bikes and easy access to the sand. For guests comparing Butler Beach vacation rentals, it stands out for the combination of a private pool, fenced yard, multiple outdoor living spaces, and a flexible layout that works well for families.

A classic beach-area stop nearby is the St. Johns County Ocean Pier, where visitors can walk the pier, enjoy the beach park setting, and connect with the busier St. Augustine Beach side of the island. The area south of Butler Beach is worth exploring too, with A1A running toward Crescent Beach, Summer Haven, and the Matanzas Inlet area and its long, open stretches of sand.

Margaritaville already sleeps 12, but families planning a reunion or multi-house beach trip can look at nearby Butler Beach houses such as A Peace of Paradise, Atlantic Bliss, and Beach Therapy. That gives extended family or friends a way to stay close without squeezing everyone into one house.