Butler Beach, St. Augustine, FL 32080
About This Building
Barefoot Trace is an oceanfront condominium community at Butler Beach, on the quieter stretch of Anastasia Island south of St. Augustine Beach proper. The Butler Beach location offers a more residential, less-crowded beach experience than the busier central beach corridor.
Why Barefoot Trace Works as a Rental
Butler Beach location. Guests who book Butler Beach properties pick this stretch specifically for the quiet – wider sand, fewer crowds, easier parking than St. Augustine Beach proper.
Oceanfront with beach access. The building's position gives guests the oceanfront experience without the foot traffic and commercial activity of the central beach.
Pool on property and standard amenity set for an oceanfront building of its character.
Location
Area view of Butler Beach. Barefoot Trace sits within this area; exact location shared after booking.
Butler Beach
Butler Beach is a residential stretch of Anastasia Island between St. Augustine Beach to the north and Crescent Beach to the south. Quieter than either, with no major commercial corridor of its own. The wider, less-crowded sand and easier parking are real features. Within ten to fifteen minutes by car you reach St. Augustine Beach restaurants and shops, the historic district, and Crescent Beach attractions.
We don't currently manage rentals at Barefoot Trace
If you're trying to book a stay here, we won't be able to help directly — but here are our nearest available vacation rentals in the area:
What We'd Bring to a Barefoot Trace Unit
We've been managing vacation rentals in St. Johns County since 1998. We know the Butler Beach market and how to position the quiet-stretch appeal for the guests who specifically want it. Renovation and design advice comes from Marty Kirkley, co-owner of First Choice Florida – before FCF he ran Eden Home Decor, and in 2005 he sponsored an Extreme Makeover: Home Edition build for the Harvey family in Hastings.
Considering professional management for your Barefoot Trace unit?
First Choice Florida already knows this building and the local market. When you're ready to hand off the day-to-day, we're the local, licensed, boutique team that runs it like our own — real 24-hour support, direct booking, and channel management.
If you own a unit at Barefoot Trace and you're evaluating management options, give us a call. We're a boutique St. Johns County operator who knows the Butler Beach market.