St. Augustine Vacation Rentals - Houses, Condos & Beach Homes Managed Since 1998

First Choice Florida manages a curated portfolio of vacation homes, condos, and beach houses across St. Augustine. We don’t aggregate every listing on the coast – we represent properties we know personally, work with owners directly, and keep our standards high.

Find your stay

Narrow by area, size, and the kind of trip you're planning - then browse our featured homes and full collection below.

Features
More filters
Clear all
5 properties match
  • Summer Haven
  • Private Pool
Clear filters
Aerial view of beachfront condos with staircases leading down to the sandy shore and nearby communal pool area.

Sea Matanzas #4

Summer Haven
2 BR 2 BA Sleeps 4
From $200/night
 Aerial view of beachfront condos with wooden staircases leading to sandy shore and a communal pool surrounded by palm trees.

Sea Matanzas #5

Summer Haven
2 BR 2 BA Sleeps 6
From $200/night
 Sea Matanzas 6 Aerial

Sea Matanzas #6

Summer Haven
2 BR 2 BA Sleeps 4
From $225/night
 Covered deck with striped cushioned seating and dining area overlooking the sandy beach and ocean waves.

Sea Matanzas #9

Summer Haven
2 BR 2 BA Sleeps 9
From $225/night
 Bright living room with ocean views and cozy seating!

Summerhouse 307

Summer Haven
2 BR 2 BA Sleeps 6
From $175/night