The Preserve
Anastasia Island, St. Augustine, FL 32080
About This Building
The Preserve is a residential condominium community on Anastasia Island in St. Augustine, in a setting that prioritizes natural surroundings and quieter residential feel over high-rise oceanfront density. The community offers comfortable family-sized units with on-property amenities.
Why The Preserve Works as a Rental
Quieter, more natural setting than the busier oceanfront corridor along A1A. Guests who pick The Preserve often want the Anastasia Island location with beach access but the residential feel of a community surrounded by natural areas rather than commercial activity.
Pool, clubhouse, and family-sized units make The Preserve viable for repeat travelers, snowbirds, and longer-stay guests.
Close to St. Augustine Beach amenities, Anastasia State Park, and historic downtown.
Location
Area view of Anastasia Island. The Preserve sits within this area; exact location shared after booking.
Anastasia Island
Anastasia Island is the barrier island that runs from north of St. Augustine Beach down to Summer Haven. The Preserve sits in the central portion of the island within a short drive of St. Augustine Beach amenities, Anastasia State Park, the Lighthouse, and historic downtown St. Augustine.
We don't currently manage rentals at The Preserve
If you're trying to book a stay here, we won't be able to help directly — but here are our nearest available vacation rentals in the area:
What We'd Bring to a The Preserve Unit
We've been managing vacation rentals in St. Johns County since 1998. We know how to position non-oceanfront Anastasia Island properties for the right guest profile. Renovation and design advice comes from Marty Kirkley, co-owner of First Choice Florida — before FCF he ran Eden Home Decor, and in 2005 he sponsored an Extreme Makeover: Home Edition build for the Harvey family in Hastings.
Considering professional management for your The Preserve unit?
First Choice Florida already knows this building and the local market. When you're ready to hand off the day-to-day, we're the local, licensed, boutique team that runs it like our own — real 24-hour support, direct booking, and channel management.
If you own a unit at The Preserve and you're evaluating management options, give us a call. We're a boutique St. Johns County operator.